Two Winning Novels about Dysfunctional Families: Commonwealth and All the Ugly and Wonderful Things

October 18, 2016 Mini Book Reviews 23

Dysfunctional families are one of my favorite topics to read about in fiction…and I was lucky enough to come across two winners this Fall.

Commonwealth, Ann PatchettCommonwealth by Ann Patchett
Fiction (Released September 13, 2016)
336 Pages
Bottom Line: Read it.
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon
Source: Purchased (Publisher: Harper)

Plot Summary: An ill fated christening party is the catalyst that ruins the Keating and Cousins marriages…and creates a blended family trying to navigate their new world.

My Thoughts: Commonwealth is a simply and perfectly told story of a cobbled together family…and is one of my favorite books of 2016 so far! Every member of the blended Keating/Cousins family behaves dreadfully, but I was somewhat sympathetic towards all of them. The four Cousins children and two Keating girls are impressively creative in their antics, but I rooted for them because their parents are so completely uninterested in and overwhelmed by them. And, it wasn’t their fault that their parents selfishly created this impossible situation. But, I also sympathized with the parents because their children’s united hatred of them resulted in an incredible amount of tormenting.

The Cousins children and the Keating children smiled up with beatific forgiveness. They had done everything they had ever wanted to do, they had had the most wonderful day, and no one even knew they were gone.

There is nothing grand about this story, no bells and whistles in the plot or the writing. But Ann Patchett can really tell a story…one that is beautiful and satisfying and reflects the mess of real life without resorting to tricks. She releases information about her characters in drips and drabs (similar to Did You Ever Have A Family) and describes scenes of mundane life that perfectly illustrate her characters:

When their father took the girls to the alley behind the grocery store at six o’clock in the morning with their racquets and fresh cans of tennis balls, Caroline would have as many as twenty-seven consecutive hits without missing. Thwack, thwack, thwack, into the blank wall that was the back of the A&P, her long arms intuitively graceful in their swing. Franny’s personal best was three consecutive hits, and that had only happened once. But the real difference between Caroline and Franny was that Caroline cared. She cared about the law and tennis and her grades in classes she didn’t even like. She cared what their father said about their mother, what he said about everything. Franny just wanted to go back to the car and read Agatha Christie.

Commonwealth is a book that I enjoyed every minute of reading. I couldn’t wait for my next opportunity to read and I didn’t want it to end.

All the Ugly and Wonderful Things, Bryn GreenwoodAll the Ugly and Wonderful Things by Bryn Greenwood
Fiction (Released August 9, 2016)
352 Pages
Bottom Line: Read it.
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon
Source: Purchased (Publisher: Thomas Dunne Books)

Plot Summary: After Wavy, the daughter of a meth dealer father and addict mother, witnesses Kellen’s (one of Wavy’s father’s “employees”) motorcycle accident, he takes her under his wing, leading to an unlikely relationship.

My Thoughts: I was all over the place with my feelings about All the Ugly and Wonderful Things, but I ended up in an emotionally invested and somewhat surprising (to me) place. I immediately loved the voice of Amy, Wavy’s cousin, and the storyline of Wavy’s integration into her extended family’s normal way of life the first of many times she stayed with them. Then, I became thoroughly creeped out by the story’s direction once Wavy returns to her parents at the ranch (her home and the site of her father’s meth cooking business). My discomfort with a specific theme of the story began to make me actually dislike the entire book. I kept saying to myself “please tell me this isn’t going there.”

But, by the halfway point, Greenwood completely brought me around again. She sold me on her creepy storyline (to the tune of 4 stars instead of the 2.5/3 stars I was considering)! I’ve read many books that started off well only to fall off a cliff later on, but it’s rare that I find one that does the opposite (Fates and Furies is the last one I can think of). Greenwood wrote in a way that demanded my sympathy for and understanding of these characters, despite my initial misgivings. Plus, the story’s action picked up considerably in the second half. Because All the Ugly and Wonderful Things addresses a controversial topic likely to spark strong feelings one way or another, it would make an excellent book club selection.

Get Weekly Email Updates!

23 Responses to “Two Winning Novels about Dysfunctional Families: Commonwealth and All the Ugly and Wonderful Things”

  1. Beth F

    I have both here … not read. My last two months were so crazy busy with work I fell behind in pleasure reading. I plan to make up for lost time.

    • Sarah Dickinson

      I hope you get to them – Commonwealth will definitely be on my Best of 2016 list!

  2. Naomi

    I’ll be adding All the Ugly and Wonderful Things to my book club list! I was hoping it would turn out to be a good one with that great title. 🙂

    • Sarah Dickinson

      It’s definitely one that some people will absolutely hate, but that’s what makes it a good book club pick, right?! No shortage of discussion.

  3. Susie | Novel Visits

    Commonwealth was truly a wonderful story. One of my favorites, also. I tried the sample of All the Ugly and Wonderful Things, but wasn’t hooked. Maybe I need to give it more time. (I agree with you about Fates and Furies!)

    • Sarah Dickinson

      Well, I initially loved Ugly/Wonderful…then got turned off…then got turned back on. So, I’m a little hesitant to push it on you if you didn’t like the beginning sample.

  4. Diane

    I loved All the Ugly and Beautiful Things, even though it made me squirm as I read. Commonwealth is a great story as well although it took me a while to get used to the decades leapsfter chapter one.

    • Sarah Dickinson

      It was completely squirmy, wasn’t it?!

      And I was a little jarred by the first time leap, but then I got used to it and really ended up liking it. Kind of like knowing the beginning and the end and working your way towards the middle. The suspense lies in the how, which generally works for me in books.

  5. Jenny @ Reading the End

    It’s not that I don’t believe you about the story coming back around and being okay after all (although I remain dubious), but it’s just that I don’t think it’s going to be the book for me. That, er, particular thing (I’m trying not to spoil it for people in the comments!) is a big squick for me.

    • Sarah Dickinson

      Hear you on the spoiler. And I don’t think I ended up thinking it was okay, more that I had sympathy for the characters and how they could get themselves in that situation….where initially I had NONE.

  6. Catherine

    Ugly and Wonderful definitely goes to an uncomfortable place, but I’m glad you ended up liking it. I really loved it, I guess because as hincky as it got, the fact that it was not about power with Kellen and Wavy made it wonderful. They were two very damaged people who had only each other.

  7. Care

    GREAT review of Commonwealth. Not sure if I want to try Ugly and Wonderful. I have so many books to read – maybe next year sometime. ha!

  8. MTH

    Ugly/Wonderful was a great read. I love a book that requires me to experience something different. Please tell me what you think of Fates and Furies, or recommend another book which will deliver an experience.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.