Best Books of 2017

Best Books of 2017

For the last few years, I’ve had trouble choosing one favorite for my Best Book of 2017, so I’ve treated my list like an Olympic event with my top 3 books as my “medalists.” But, this year I had one overwhelming favorite. No other book even came close. 

While I’m thrilled to have a secure best book of 2017, this year was difficult overall. There just weren’t as many books that blew me away as in previous years. And, the books that worked really well for me were lighter than my usual fare. But, there’s nothing wrong with some crackling brain candy and I read a couple outstanding ones this year.

I was also on a completely different wavelength than the serious literary critics (via their Best Books of 2017 lists…more on this in a later post) and I didn’t love many of the books that publishers pushed the most (see my post on 2017 Books that Deserved the Hype…and Those That Didn’t).

Finally, I’ve brought back the high school yearbook-style “Superlatives” from previous years (201620152014) and stay tuned for my first ever Best Audiobooks I Listened to in 2017 list (coming on December 28)!

Best Books of 2017

My #1 Book of 2017

The Heart’s Invisible Furies by John Boyne (review)
Most Likely to Make my All-Time Favorites List

Closest Reading Experience I’ve Had to A Little Life (minus the relentless physical abuse) 
Caused My Most Recent Book Hangover
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

The Rest of My Favorites

Beartown by Fredrick Backman (review)
Best Author Comeback (I DNF’d A Man Called Ove)

Best Sports Book That’s About Far More Than Sports
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

Dead Letters by Caite Dolan-Leach (review)
Most Recommended and Purchased (via my Affiliate Links) Book of 2017
Most Demented Twins
Best Balance Between Literary and Brain Candy
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

Emma in the Night by Wendy Walker (review)
Best Thriller of 2017 (and Best Thriller I’ve Read Since Gone Girl)

Best Balance Between Surprising, Yet Not Outlandish Ending
Most Dysfunctional Family
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio (review)
Best Campus Novel

Best Debut
Most Sinister
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

Quicksand by Malin Persson Giolito (review)
Most Messed Up High School Students

Best Book in Translation
Most Underrated Gem
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugoby Taylor Jenkins Reid (review)
Biggest Surprise

Best of the Brain Candy
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

This Is How It Always Is by Laurie Frankel (review)
Most Endearing Family

Biggest Range of Emotions
Best “Issue” Book
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

Trophy Son by Douglas Brunt (review)
Best Sports Book

Hit Closest to Home
Best Non-Traditional Coming of Age Story
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon

White Fur by Jardine Libaire (review)
Best Writing

Best Social Commentary about the Wealthy
Best Non-Traditional Love Story
Affiliate Link: Buy from Amazon 

What were your favorite books of 2017?

Get Weekly Email Updates!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Wendy wrote:

    Book hangover? The End of the World Running Club. That was a surprisingly good read. Best book? I might be reading it right now…

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  2. renee wrote:

    Heart’s will be at my top as well! We’ve had a similar reading year for many books…I loved Evelyn, Trophy Son and Beartown as well. Here’s hoping we all have a terrible time choosing next year! Hope your holidays are relaxing and reading filled Sarah

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  3. There are so many on your list that I haven’t gotten to yet! I did read Dead Letters, which I enjoyed as well! Many on your list might be up over my winter break 🙂

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  4. Ann Marie wrote:

    Great list, Sarah! The on;y one I’ve read is The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo and I really enjoyed it! I just added a few of these to my list.

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  5. I’m not surprised that our top book is the same! It was just so great. I really debated on White Fur and This is How It Always Is. Had I included two more, it would have been those.

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  6. Michelle wrote:

    Beartown is another book that continues to haunt me.

    There may not have been a lot of excellent books this year, but the ones we found were all but life-altering!

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  7. My wish list always groans this time of year. I’ve only read 2 of those books – thankfully I own several others. I need to put The Heart’s Invisible Furies higher up my stacks.

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  8. This is basically my tbr list for the next few months! Looking forward to starting 2018 with The Heart’s Invisible Furies.

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  9. Sarah R wrote:

    I loved Saints for all Occasions, Station Eleven, Stranger in the Woods, The Nazi Officer’s Wife, and 84 Charing Cross Road. It’s weird to me that of these books, 3 came out well before 2017.

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  10. Heather wrote:

    Dead Letters was surprisingly good. I read that one a couple of years ago. Looks like a great year of reading!

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  11. Annie wrote:

    Heart’s was my favorite as well! This Is How It Always is came in second if I had to rank it! Thanks for this list, you just moved a few up my TBR PILE!

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  12. Great list! While I’ve been circling Bear Town for months now, your review is what made me get hold of a copy today.

    Posted 12.12.17 Reply
  13. Tara wrote:

    There really were quite a few great reads this year; I’m still so thankful that you encouraged me to read Trophy Son – that was such a winner!

    Posted 12.13.17 Reply
  14. Ohh I haven’t read any but really curious about several of these now!

    Posted 12.13.17 Reply
  15. iliana wrote:

    I always love reading best of lists because of course it’s a great way to add more titles to my radar 🙂 I haven’t read any of your favorites but some are on my stacks.

    Posted 12.13.17 Reply
  16. I just finished Bear Town – loved that one as well. Ha – it’s funny, my list right now is so, so long! I have the opposite problem as you.

    Posted 12.13.17 Reply
  17. Catherine wrote:

    Well, only four of mine are on your list so maybe we’re moving from identical reading twins to fraternal? I couldn’t even come up with 10 2017 releases I loved so my list is going to include backlist. Having said that, my two favorite books of the year are: Heart’s Invisible Furies and This is How It Always Is.

    Posted 12.13.17 Reply
  18. Lindsey wrote:

    The only book on your list that I’ve read so far is The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo. But I’m seeing The Heart’s Invisible Furies A LOT lately. I think I will have to pick it up in 2018!

    Posted 12.14.17 Reply
  19. Lauren wrote:

    I had mixed thoughts on many of these, but I haven’t talked to anyone who has read This Is How It Always Is that didn’t feel like it was one of their top reads. Same with the Boyne, so I’m anxious to get to that one even thought the page count gives me hives.

    Posted 12.15.17 Reply
  20. Andrea wrote:

    I feel so validated in my feelings towards Ove now!! Haha. I agree on Beartown, too. 🙂 I think there will be a few that overlap on my best 2017 of list!

    Posted 12.15.17 Reply
  21. So we know we’re not in agreement on some of these (lol) and I haven’t read Beartown and a few other ones on your list, but we’re definitely on the same wavelength for This Is How It Always is – so there’s that! 🙂

    Posted 12.17.17 Reply
    • Sarah Dickinson wrote:

      Ha – yes, I remember! But I do feel like we’ve been on the same page about other books this year that didn’t make our Best of lists.

      Posted 12.18.17 Reply
  22. Beartown, Emma in the Night, and If We Were Villains are some of my favorites this year too! I have been letting the length of The Heart’s Invisible Furies scare me away from reading it, but it is calling to me from my shelf!

    Posted 12.18.17 Reply
    • Sarah Dickinson wrote:

      Oh my gosh – do not let it scare you! I’m the queen of having trouble with long books and I didn’t have any trouble with this one. It flows so well and isn’t a slog at all. I think you’d love it:)

      Posted 12.18.17 Reply
  23. I really enjoyed Emma in the Night too! I’m a little nervous to pick up Beartown, because it seems a bit darker than the books by Backman I’ve read previously (I loved A Man Called Ove :)) but I expect I’ll get to it eventually.

    Posted 12.18.17 Reply
    • Sarah Dickinson wrote:

      It’s definitely pretty dark, but I love dark 🙂 And I wasn’t a huge fan of Ove…DNF’d it around 40% or so.

      Posted 12.19.17 Reply
  24. Ann Marie wrote:

    Awesome list, Sarah! I’ve asked for Lillian Boxfish Takes and Walk and The Heart’s Invisible Furies. No matter how many books I read and acquire throughout the year, a few always manage to slip by.

    Posted 12.20.17 Reply
    • Sarah Dickinson wrote:

      Did you get them?!

      Posted 12.29.17 Reply
  25. Thanks for convincing me to read The Heart’s Invisible Furies. I was worried it would feel long and I wouldn’t get through it before the end of the year, but I got it out from the library and read it in about a week. It ended up being my novel of the year too! I know I can trust your discriminating taste.

    Posted 12.26.17 Reply
    • Sarah Dickinson wrote:

      Oh yay!! I was worried about the same thing b/c long books haven’t been working for me lately. But, this one did not FEEL long and that’s the key.

      And I didn’t know I had discriminating taste – thank you!! 🙂

      Posted 12.29.17 Reply
  26. Bryan wrote:

    Hmmm. I hadn’t heard of Emma in the Night. I’ll have to look for that one.

    Posted 12.31.17 Reply

Get Weekly Email Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive all new blog posts in one weekly email. Plus, news of special updates and offers!

You have Successfully Subscribed!